Home | About Me | Links to My Articles | Info on My Book | Contact Me
Welcome to MahdiWatch.org!
NEWSFLASH! COMMENTS LINK
BELOW EACH POST IS ENABLED! FEEL FREE TO BURY ME, PRAISE ME--OR JUST ISSUE A PERSONAL FATWA!
al-Mahdi is "the rightly-guided one" who, according to Islamic Hadiths (traditions),
will come before the end of time to make the entire world Muslim. Over the last 1400 years numerous claimants to the
mantle of the Mahdi have arisen in both Shi`i and Sunni circles. Modern belief in the coming of the Mahdi has
manifested most famously in the 1979 al-`Utaybi uprising of Sa`udi Arabia, and most recently in the ongoing
Mahdist movements (some violent) in Iraq, as well as in the frequently-expressed public prayers of Iranian
President Ahmadinezhad bidding the Mahdi to return and, in the larger Sunni Islamic world, by claims that Usamah bin Ladin
might be the (now occulted?) Mahdi. This site will track such Mahdi-related movements, aspirations, propaganda and beliefs
in both Sunni and Shi`i milieus, as well as other Muslim eschatological yearnings.
For a primer on Mahdism, see my 2005 article, "What's Worse than Violent Jihadists?," at the History News
Network: http://hnn.us/articles/13146.html; for more in-depth info, see the links here to my other writings, including my book on Mahdism.
Thursday, April 17, 2014
al-Qaida Comes to Jesus--the Muslim One, Unfortunately
12:23 pm edt
The American media and US intelligence community have both--as usual--missed the point about yesterday's al-Qa`ida jihad-fest in Yemen, in which AQ deputy caliph Nasir al-Wuhayshi calls for Muslims to "eliminate the cross" and "the bearer of
the cross [which] is America." CNN, FNC and various and sundry US government analysts and politicians over the past 24
hours have exegeted the video of this meeting to mean that 1) we should have had armed drones there sooner, and 2) our intelligence
is still lacking, if the CIA was indeed unaware of this mass AQ confab.
Important as these two issues are, however,
they are both tactical ones, and thus of lesser importance than the glaringly obvious strategic point made by al-Wuhayshi:
AQ does not want to attack America primarily because of our "freedoms" but because we are the largest Christian country on the planet.
This inconvenient truth flies in the face of both post-9/11 US administrations. Only 9 days after
the Islamic terrorist attacks that killed 3,000 Americans, President Bush was misconstruing the perpetrators as "enemies of freedom." President Obama and his willfully ignorant mouthpieces (like Eric Holder and John Brennan) have doubled down on this nonsense, and even exceeded it by their constant claims that the very idea that Islam might have
had something to do with motivating those engaged in self-described jihad is ipso facto discriminatory. (A variation of this head-in-the-sand "analsyis" holds that "religious fundamentalists'" hatred of modernity is the culprit.)
Alas, the secularists and
leftists in downtown Atlanta, Manhattan, Foggy Bottom and Langley are wrong, and as long as they continue to be wrong the
West will go on losing its civilizational battle--which is not just with Islamic "extremism" or AQ but
with literalist Islam itself.
Why? Because the Qur'an and the Hadiths (alleged sayings of Muhammad) instruct
Muslims to labor, violently and non-violently, until the entire world is either converted or submissive to Islam. And
since historically and theologically the main (indeed, only) rival to Islam has been Christianity, that religion and
its adherents have been the object of the lion's share of Islamic ire--and most of that long before AQ even existed.
Recall that the majority of the Middle East and North Africa west of the Tigris and Euphrates was Christian by the
7th century AD. It was only after the irruption of Islam from Arabia and the "destruction of tens of thousands of churches" that the intolerant religion of Muhammad gained the upper hand in those regions.
AQ's #2 calling for a jihad, an Islamic religious war, against Christians is nothing new; neither is it
"extremist." Such has been the norm for most of the last fourteen centuries, and Americans have simply
been lulled into lassitude by the earlier 20th century retreat of Islamic aggression (along with, it must be said, American
ignorance of history courtesy of shoddy public schools, as well as books, lectures and coverage by dhimmi media and their
"experts"). AQ is weaponized Islam; but it is not the first version, nor will it be the last.
are even hadiths which state that when "prophet Jesus" (nabi `Isa) returns from heaven--for of course he was never crucified and thus never
resurrected, but simply taken up--he will kill all the world's pigs, destroy all the crosses and then kneel
down and pray behind the Mahdi, who outranks him. AQ is thus following mainstream Islamic teachings (both Sunni and
Twelver Sh`i) in eschatological matters, as well more mundane ones.
A drone strike on al-Wuhayshi and his
Muslim brothers in Yemen was necessary; but it would have been woefully insufficient to stem the tide of Islamic ideology,
of da`wah, which continues to captivate the vast majority of Muslims in the Middle East, as well as growing numbers
of supporters in America and the West. (For example: the Boston Marathon jihad of the brothers Tsarnaev was motivated, at least in part, by Islamic eschaological belief.) As long as the American intelligentsia and leadership
denies that many members of the world's second-largest religion are waging war on the adherents of the largest one,
al-Wuhayshi and his ilk will have the upper hand.
Jesus and the Mahdi, back from a hard day of destroying churches, hit the drive-thru at Sonic Boom Falafel.
Tuesday, April 15, 2014
Happy Den of Thievery Day!
Actually, I'm not a formal member of the Tea Party (which works, here in the US, for the decidely
non-radical agenda of lower taxes, smaller government and adherence to the Constitution) and I realize that
when Christ cleared the money-lenders from the Temple, he was rescuing His Father's house from the taint of greed and not
advocating for tax cuts. But still, the juxtaposition between April 15 (the deadline by which Americans must pay all
taxes owed for the previous year) and Holy Week was just too rich to pass up.
9:27 am edt
Monday, April 14, 2014
Eschatological Nature of Holy Week
9:41 am edt
Wednesday, March 26, 2014
I'm Not the Mahdi--Now $%*# Off!
Many analysts and journalists who cover the Islamic world focus on the likes of
al-Qa`idah [“al-Qaeda” for those of you from Monkey’s Eyebrow, KY] and the Muslim Brotherhood.
Far fewer spend much time on an equally important Islamic movement: that of the Turkish neo-mystic Fethullah Gülen. (For a rough metric
of the relevant interest in these three, try a Google search for each and you’ll find the following results: AQ, 107
million; MB, 86 million; Gülen,
1.3 million.) Such relative disinterest is unfortunate, because this Turkish-American movement (Gülen has lived in Pennsylvania since his eviction
from a much more secular Turkey in 1991) is important on three levels: 1) Mahdism; 2) global educational
reach; and 3) within Turkish politics.
10:43 am edt
No, this is not a selfie of Shelob, but
rather Ottoman calligraphy that reads "Ali, vice-regent of Allah."
In terms of Mahdism,
both Gülen and another prominent,
albeit much more idiosyncratic, Turkish religious leader named Adnan Oktar, are devotees of the late Turkish mystic Said Nursi (d. 1960), known to his followers as “Bediüzzaman” (Arabic badi` al-zaman, “wonder of the age”). Nursi
in his writings stressed the compability of Islam with modern science and education, and advocated “jihad of the word”
over “jihad of the sword.” Nursi very likely considered himself to be a, if not the,
Mahdi—tantamount to the Islamic mujaddid, “renewer,” who is predicted in some hadiths to come every
century. That would seem to be the same view that Gülen holds of himself, as evidenced by an interview in “Today’s Zaman” last Friday: “I am not claiming to be the Messiah or Mahdi; I am just an
ordinary man….” He continued: “Some circles have attributed similar remarks to Bediüzzaman in the past. They exploited his comments
and views on the return of the Messiah or Mahdi, arguing that he considered himself the Mahdi or Messiah.”
reiterated his denial: “On this matter, I follow in the footsteps of Mevlana [Jalal al-Din Muhammad Rûmi, d. 1273 AD). I am not claiming to be the Messiah or Mahdi.”
Also like Nursi, Gülen
is an Islamic mystic but holds no formal membership in any of the hundreds of tariqat, or Sufi orders.
His educational system, however, is pedagogically and religiously a mixture of Nursi’s ideas
and Gülen’s thought, with
a dose of Naqshbandi Sufism—specifically, the need to be involved in politics—thrown in. (On this topic, see Erol
N. Gulay, “The Gülen Phenomenon:
A Neo-Sufi Challenge to Turkey’s Rival Elite,” in C ritique: Critical Modern Middle Eastern Studies,
Vol. 16, No. 1, Spring 2007, pp. 37-61.) The “Gülenistas” have created perhaps the world’s largest charter school system, which as of 2012 was also the largest such system in the United States, numbering 135 schools and 45,000 students. Although the schools in
America are said by administrators and proponents to be STEM-oriented ones that eschew Islamic indoctrination,
critics are doubtful. Overseas, particularly in Muslim-majority countries,
Gülen schools unabashedly teach
Islam—but a neo-Sufi, indeed kinder and gentler version of that faith than is disseminated by the Wahhabis and Salafis of Arabia or the Deobandi-influenced
Taliban of South Asia.
the ruling AK Party of Turkey—particularly its leader and the current Prime Minister, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan—has increasingly been at loggerheads with Gülen and his people, accusing them of constituting a “deep state” which wields the real
power behind the scenes. The actual reasons for this split between two erstwhile allies are byzantine (pun intended), but seem to center around
who has more power in Turkey; view of and relations with Israel vis-à-vis other Muslim states; and the profits from
Turkey’s gold-for-oil trade with Iran.
Leaked AK plan to take out Gülen during his coffee break. Left-handed guitarist
killing is optional, especially if he's singing "Band on the Run."
1) As I’ve remarked before, I’ll take any day, and twice on Friday, a Mahdi or Mujaddid who states
that “the conquest of the world will be achieved, not on the back of a horse, a sword in the hand,
a scimitar at the waist” but rather by “penetrating into people’s hearts with the Qur’an in one hand
and reason in the other” (Gulay, p. 42)—as has Gülen. This IS truly moderate
Islam, and far from lumping Gülen’s people in with the jihadists we should be encouraging the spread of his charter schools across
the Islamic world, with their Sufi Lite message of educational, not bloody, jihad (which, really, is tantamount to da`wah,
2) However, also regarding these charter schools and their place in the US (or
any other non-Islamic society): great scrutiny should be applied to them here, to ensure that they stick
to teaching science, technology, engineering and math and do not attempt to inculcate Islamic values among the 99.4%
of the US population that is non-Muslim. If they can do that, let them operate. If not, shut them down
more quickly than Duke in this year's NCAA tournament.
3) Regarding Turkey’s internal politics and this Erdoğan-Gülen struggle—I don’t have a dog in that fight, but it
looks increasingly as if the latter is the only force that can prevent the former from asserting neo-Ottoman-style authoritarian
power. A Gülenized Turkey might become the first truly moderate Islamic state; certainly the Gülenists are much more likely to drive such a
result than the poseur moderates like the Muslim Brotherhood.
Today's post title comes from Monty Python's brilliant
1979 satire of messianism, "Life of Brian"--specifically, the scene "I'm not the Messiah!"
Monday, March 17, 2014
Don't Lose Your Head Over Mahdi Beheading Threats
While in Iran in the summer of 2008 to present a paper at the annual Mahdism conference in Tehran,
I sat in on a number of panels that discussed various aspects of the future rule of the returned Twelfth
Imam. (My own presentation compared self-proclaimed Sunni Mahdis to the Twelver Shi`i prognostications about this expected
utopian rule by their “true” Mahdi.) As I reported in my post-trip article
“The Importance of Being Mahdist” (in The Weekly Standard), one Iranian presenter discussed whether the
Mahdi would allow non-Muslims to convert—or simply kill us all. Opinion was divided
as to which was more likely, although as I recall the latter option was deemed well within the Rightly-Guided One’s
purview. As a Christian, and American, I decided then was not the time to offer my own two riyal’s
11:38 am edt
No detail was provided as to the Mahdi’s preferred execution
method—until now. According to a Mehr story, explicated by Reza Kahlili in The Daily Caller, last week the interim Friday prayer leader in Iran’s capital, Ayatollah
Muhammad Emani Kashani, warned that “when Imam Zaman [“Imam of Time,” or the Mahdi] comes, he will behead
the Western leaders” although he will “not harm the oppressed nations.”
At least with the Mahdi, only beheading of infidels--not impaling--will be required.
1) Khalili’s hyperventilating aside, the idea of the Mahdi as a violent Islamic
warlord is neither new nor—for any of my readers from the CIA or mainstream media—a “hijacking”
of the concept. Also, it is not particularly Shi`i. Both Sunnis
and Shi`is believe in this eschatological figure who will create a global caliphate, mainly via force. (As
I’ve explained many times on this site and in other writings and lectures, the biggest difference
in the Muslim view of the Mahdi is that Sunnis think he has not been here yet, while Twelver Shi`is think he is a blood descendant
of Muhammad who disappeared in the 8th c. AD and will return.) The Mahdi simply emulates and recapitulates
the mission and career of Muhammad—and thus is not, contra Khalili, a “prophet” because he brings
no new message from Allah but simply continues and expands Islamic conquest.
2) Decapitation is a favorite method of Islamic execution of “infidels,” and has been
practiced by Muslims—both leader and lay—for millennia. Again, it is not “extremist”
in Islamic terms. Please see my heavily-sourced article “Beheading in the Name of Islam” if you have any doubts as to the Islamic legitimacy of the practice.
3) Khalili’s article also adduces a 2011 eschatological
video sponsored by the Iranian government. I broke down this video, in terms of Mahdist tropes and images,
in an article for History News Network entitled “Iran’s New Mahdism Da`wah Video: Letting Slip the Jinns of Jihad?” At the risk of hubris, I think my analysis is more comprehensive than his, especially
as regards the clear influence of Evangelical Christian eschatological writings on the Islamic world.
4) Ayatollah Kashani’s reference to the Mahdi not harming “oppressed
nations” (nor, presumably, their leaders) is part-and-parcel of the Islamic Republic’s “Muslim liberation
theology” rhetoric, which crudely divides the world into mostazafan, “oppressed,” and mostakhbaran,
“oppressors.” The sources for such a worldview are two: Twelver Shi`ism’s victimization
mentality, and modern Iranian thinkers’ and clerics’ neo-Marxist influences. Since 1979 Iran
has been using this ideology as part of its global da`wah in both creating an anti-Western/Christian bloc, and in
spreading (Twelver Shi`i) Islam to the Sunni masses in Africa and southeast Asia, and even to the Christians of Latin America
(as seems to have worked with Hugo Chavez).
5) Yes, Christianity also has its violent eschatological figure—the Second Coming Christ,
particularly as described in Revelation 19:11ff: eyes of flame, riding a white horse, robe dipped in blood, wielding a sword
and a rod of iron which he uses to kill His enemies. However, there is a major difference
between Christianity and Islam in terms of each’s violent messiah. In Christendom, it’s difficult
bordering on impossible for an earthly leader to assume or claim to be the returned Christ and lead such a crusade (the few
exceptions, such as Hong Xiuquan, leader of the 19th c. Taiping Rebellion in China, prove the rule). In
the Islamic world, on the other hand, self-styled Mahdis leading jihads have been a staple of history in both Sunni and Shi`i
realms (although predominantly in the former). I fully explored this topic in a paper I wrote for an eschatology
conference at Georgia State University, the condensed version of which is available here.
(This post's title comes from one of Queen's lesser-known songs, "Don't Lose Your Head"--which was the unofficial soundtrack to the movie "Highlander.")
|Jamkaran Mosque near Qom, Iran (during my trip there Aug. 2008)